REVIEW: DUTCH #1 (of 3)

Dutch originally belonged to Team Youngblood, a group different from other Youngblood characters because Chad Yaep created and owns him. This means he is not involved in any disagreements over rights. Therefore, it is fascinating to see a Youngblood character reappear in Image Comics. Dutch #1 stands out from simply catering to nostalgia, which is commendable. Joe Casey, who is knowledgeable about Youngblood lore, chooses to tell the story of Dutch’s development in real-time, which is a refreshing change. Instead of following the usual trope of a young soldier transforming into a superhero for fame and endorsements, Dutch is portrayed as a seasoned veteran tired of his past. Reluctantly, he is drawn back into a world he had desperately tried to leave behind.

Casey’s rendition of Dutch resonates with echoes of Old Man Logan, a portrayal befitting the character, setting him apart from previous attempts at revitalizing Extreme Studios’ creations. Dutch #1 bears resemblance to the recent Local Man series by Tony Fleecs and Tim Seeley. Both narratives explore the realm of retrospection regarding Image’s past, devoid of derision. They scrutinize the original premise of superheroes existing in the real world, pondering its implications three decades later. While the trope of retired soldiers coerced into one last mission may seem familiar, its execution within the context of Image’s tumultuous history offers a fresh perspective.

The difference between Dutch’s world in 2024 and that of 1994 is clearly shown through the artistry. Simone Gane’s detailed linework, combined with Francesco Segula’s choice of colors, enhanced by Gloria Martinelli’s contributions, create a noticeable change in tone. While the visuals still convey energy and movement, the character designs exhibit a more refined and subtle style, diverging from the exaggerated aesthetic of the ’90s.

Dutch’s appearance and behavior show that he has lived a challenging life filled with difficult tasks, which reflects his age and the things he has gone through. This is a testament to Casey’s skill in storytelling. Even supporting characters like Infiniti, who used to be a member of Youngblood, go through a unique aging process, breaking away from the usual way female characters are portrayed. Gane skillfully manages the action scenes and body language, making the narrative of this action-adventure story even more captivating.

The use of muted colors by Segula and Martinelli emphasizes the striking difference between the present and the vibrant neon style of the ’90s. Although Dutch #1 tells an engaging story, people who are not familiar with the B-tier Youngblood characters from the ’90s may not fully appreciate its impact. However, for fans of Local Man and classic ’90s comics, this release is a significant addition that is definitely worth exploring.

This is a story of  an aging hero who embarks on a final mission long after their prime, the book manages to make Dutch a likable main character, which is a credit to its merit. Dutch doesn’t criticize the current state of affairs or idolize past generations with a misguided rant about America losing its way. Overall, the opening issue may not be groundbreaking, but it effectively executes familiar storytelling elements.